1. Strengthen an argument
Nadia’s family is spending Saturday at the local outdoor pool. Her dad tells the children: “Put on more sunscreen after every swim, even if you put some on at home before we came.”
Which one of these statements, if true, best supports the dad’s claim?
- ASunburn is more common in summer than at any other time of year.
- BSunscreen works best when put on twenty minutes before going into the sun.
- CWater washes a lot of sunscreen off the skin while a person is swimming.
- DLifeguards at the pool wear wide hats and long sleeves while they are on duty.
Show the working
Look for: a fact that gives a reason for the dad's rule.
Working
- The claim: put on more sunscreen after every swim, even if you put some on at home.
- So the answer must explain why the sunscreen from home is not enough after a swim.
- C says water washes a lot of sunscreen off. That is exactly why you would put more on after swimming.
- A, B and D are about sunburn in summer, when to put sunscreen on, and lifeguards. None explains putting more on after a swim.
Answer: C
The trap: B is about sunscreen and sounds sensible, but it is about when to put it on, not why to put it on again.